jump to navigation

Network employment & collective self-employment 22 February 2011

Posted by cooperatoby in cooperative, EU, Social enterprise.
Tags: , ,
trackback

I went to the European ‘Mutual Learning’ seminar on self-employment last November, and felt a bit like a specimen in a jar, or Banquo’s ghost at the feast. All around me academics and employment service officials, employers and trade unionists were trying to make sense of this strange species of self-employed people. The tools they have to understand us are not up to the job.
The way they look at us is that we are poor failures who can’t hack it in the world of being employed. People only become self-employed for short periods between ‘proper jobs’, and they only use the term as a figleaf to disguise the shameful fact that what they are is actually UNemployed. The fact that there are people who have been happily and productively self-employed for decades seems to have escaped their notice entirely.
I spoke up about this, as the token self-employed person in the room. Perhaps naively, I was surprised that my version of reality didn’t appear in the minutes of the meeting.
This is anomalous at a time when the European Commission is trying to stimulate entrepreneurship; indeed immediately after the thematic review on self-employment came the launch of the European Progress Microfinance Facility, which is designed to encourage more self-employment. Yet there still seems to be a terrifyingly corporatist view – that self-employment is somehow abnormal, and even maybe a bit shady.
Grey zone
Theorists seem to want to divide the world of work into two species: employers and workers. They are thought to have different motivations – employers love innovation, create wealth and jobs, and have to be incentivised with tax breaks, while workers are stick-in-the-muds whose wage demands have to be held in check. I don’t feel that I fit into either of these catgories. I have about 30 customers or employers, with whom I have long-term relationships and who use me for jobs from time to time. It’s not an anonymous red-in-tooth-and-claw spot market. By some version of the 80/20 rule, at any one time a handful of these account for most of my time. Both parties treat this relationship as a long-term one, and there is considerable loyalty on both sides, even though there is no contract that enforces it. It is a voluntary collaboration that can be dissolved at any time. It suits both sides because the ’employer’ can tailor its freelance workfroce to the fluctuating work in hand, and the freelance can gain varied experience by working on different projects, and can pick and choose to fit their ethical beliefs and preferences. I think we need a new concept for this: I would propose ‘network employment’.
Collectives too
There’s another positive aspect of self-employment that seems to be largely off the policy map, too. This is the way that groups of people in search of self-actualisation can gain control over their working lives by setting up worker co-operatives. This sort ofcollective self-employment is longer lasting than the individual type.

Postscipt – second thoughts

Finally, three and a half years later, at an EU research seminar on self employment on 21 May 2015, Patricia Leighton describes the rise of the independent professional in a recognisable way that makes it sound fun!

Advertisements

Comments»

1. What progressives should propose is social enterprise | Toby at tipp(l)ing point - 15 November 2013

[…] our economies need to be based on a combination of self-employment and co-operation (18:00 in the video). He calls it “the reconstitution of free labour” • civil society […]

2. The individualist fixation of inclusive entrepreneurship « Toby at tipp(l)ing point - 21 November 2012

[…] through inclusive entrepreneurship – and what a change has been wrought over policy since the Mutual Learning seminar 2 years ago. Back then, the people on the platform seemed to view self-employment as very much the poor […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: